Mick McQuaid

2023-11-06

Week TWELVE

# Visual Information

## Bertin

〈 Pause for Bertin slideshow 〉

## Visual information example

Thanks to the two students who worked with me on this study of one student’s solution to the Bertin exercise. This study is more detailed than what I expected you to do in class but serves to illustrate the process.

bertin exercise example

## The Invariant

The invariant is represented by the title

## The components

The components are the things that vary in the graphic

## Retinal Variables

The retinal variables are the things that form an image on our retinas

## Bertin’s Theory

It should not be surprising that information design owes so much to a cartographer. This is one of two fields, the other being social network analysis, with the most influence on building information containers today. The remaining sections of this chapter explore Bertin’s theory of information graphics.

## Theories

The word theory is used to mean many things. To obtain a useful definition, it might be helpful to consider what Stephen Hawking says about theory in A Brief History of Time on page 7.

Note that Hawking is giving what we might call a normative definition, telling us what a theory should be. There might be plenty of things parading around under the theory banner that could be classed as bad theory. Note also that Hawking requires that a theory both describe and predict. Bertin does both of these things, with a detailed description of graphical information and using a concept called efficiency to predict outcomes.

## Efficiency

Bertin defines efficiency as a measure of how quickly the process of reading a graphic can be completed and defines the process in some detail under the influence of (then) contemporary philosophy. Let’s read some information graphics now to get an idea of what this might entail.

## Categories of information graphics

Bertin describes four categories of graphics: diagrams, networks, maps, and symbols. It is the use of the last three categories, coupled with the detail in Bertin’s theory, that persuade me that here is a good foundation for describing information architecture.

## Simplification

Recall my earlier question about adjuncts to efficiency. The main adjunct in my opinion is an exhaustive depiction of what it means to simplify information using retinal variables at the most detailed level possible.

A Picasso nude exemplifies simplicity

# Visual Design of Information

## Different perspectives drive different views

When we analyze what people see, we bring a perspective, in part based on where we are and what we do. Think about some bases for your perspective on the visible variables in presenting information, such as professional, cultural and biological.

## An important perspective

When art critics get together they talk about Form and Structure and Meaning. When artists get together they talk about where you can buy cheap turpentine.

— Pablo Picasso

quoted by Steve McConnell, Code Complete (1993)

## Another perspective

Modern philosophers have had little to say about the nature of aesthetic interest; … The concentration has been on the philosophy of art, and in particular on puzzles created by boring impostors like Duchamp: is this signed urinal a work of art? etc. This makes for an exceedingly dull literature, devoted to questions which can be answered in any way while leaving everything important exactly as it is.

—Roger Scruton, Modern Philosophy (1994), p. 589

## Essence

Several famous pictures in the twentieth century illustrate the quest to depict the essence of things. The difficulty of doing so and the effort required to see the essence before depicting it can be found in a series of lithographs created by Picasso in a short period of time. There are essays about this series available online and many versions of pictures of them. This particular version is chronologically read first from left to right then top to bottom.

Picasso’s Bull Lithographs

## More on Essence

There are many ways to interpret the word essence in the above series and I leave that to the essays mentioned above, that discuss the bull as the essence of masculinity or of Spain itself. Let me just add this proposed Olympics poster, undoubtedly influenced by Picasso in particular and Cubism in general.

## Gestalt principles

• proximity: proximate images form a group
• similarity: similar images form a group
• closure: perception completes images that appear to have missing parts
• symmetry: perception links unconnected symmetric images
• common fate: images perceived to have common fate (follow a path) form a group
• continuity: continuous images form a group
• prägnanz: images that seem to work well together form a group

## Dieter Rams

• Good design is innovative.
• Good design makes a product useful.
• Good design is aesthetic.
• Good design helps us to understand a product.
• Good design is unobtrusive.
• Good design is honest.
• Good design is durable.
• Good design is consequent to the last detail.
• Good design is concerned with the environment.
• Good design is as little design as possible.

## Edward Tufte

• Comparisons–Show comparisons, contrasts, differences
• Causality, Mechanism, Structure, Explanation
• Integration of Evidence—Integrate words, numbers, images, diagrams
• Documentation—label what data you have and measurements, etc.
• Content Counts Most of All—depend on quality, relevance, and integrity

## Get a GRIP and forget about CRAP

• grouping: group like elements together; separate disparate elements
• restatement: clarify meaning by repetition
• implied lines: align objects to minimize visual distraction
• popout: make some objects appear more prominently than others

# Visual Information Components

• Color
• Typography
• Layout
• Animation

We explored these when surveying prototyping in week 7.

# References

Bertin, Jacques. 2011. Semiology of Graphics: Diagrams, Networks, Maps (English Translation). Redlands, CA: ESRI Press.
Tufte, Edward R. 2001. The Visual Display of Quantitative Information. Cheshire, Conn: Graphics Press.

END

# Colophon

This slideshow was produced using quarto

Fonts are League Gothic and Lato